Skip to content

Haste may lay Ewing Church to waste

August 21, 2009

Time is what makes historic buildings and places historic.  It is time that creates the patina of age that makes the copper facades of the Hoboken Ferry Terminal a rich green.  It is time that has helped add to the significance of Eeero Saarinen’s masterwork Bell Labs, as his architectural innovations have come to be more appreciated while world-changing scientific advancements have occurred within its glass walls.  And it is time that has made the “someplaces” of countless historic neighborhoods in New Jersey and across America the fondly remembered and presently cherished homes for our people.

Time was available for a moment for the First Presbyterian Church of Ewing recently, when PNJ offered to take the 142-year-old-landmark, assume responsibility and liability, lead a fundraising effort and a rehabilitation project, and find a community-friendly ongoing use.    Haste may see the church’s demise.

The church Session – the governing body of First Presbyterian – gave PNJ representatives, and supportive congregation members, 45 minutes on a recent summer evening to propose saving the sanctuary while saving the church more than $100,000 in demolition costs.  Only at the meeting did PNJ learn that the church leadership would not agree to a future use that included any religious functions, because of feared “competition” across the street.  We proposed that PNJ would lead in creation of a community-based organization that would help craft a long term plan for the sanctuary’s use and agreeing to abide by the Presbytery’s restrictions and expectations.  PNJ was in it for the long term: it is our mission to preserve historic places!  All we asked for was time: a delay in demolition plans while PNJ, the Church and the regional Presbytery could negotiate for a happy conclusion to this sad and long-boiling conflict.

Time was not, however, on the side of the stone sanctuary at the bend of Scotch Road:  a two hour closed door meeting of the Session ended that evening with a brief statement whose conclusion meant that no more time was available to find a solution, make a plan, reach an agreement.

Historic buildings are all about time.  Haste usually has sad consequences.  Certainly it has created them at the bend of Scotch Road.

More of the story

4 Comments leave one →
  1. Carol Vernam Hill permalink
    August 25, 2009 4:31 pm

    After months and months of doing battle with the session, we cannot give up the fight! The Kulls, as well as Preservation New Jersey and all of the people who have worked so hard, have set the tone and we have heard their battle-cry. While there is a glimmer of hope we must continue until we convince the session that it’s OK to say “we made a mistake….that people really do care….that we need to save this mighty fortress for future generations”.


  1. Church board rejects PNJ’s preservation offer for 1st Presbyterian of Ewing; demolition to proceed « PreserveNJ
  2. PNJ to meet with Ewing Church board; offers to acquire church to preserve it « PreserveNJ
  3. Sign the online petition to Save Ewing 1st Presbyterian Church « PreserveNJ

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: